Fiber Cement vs Vinyl vs Clapboard Siding (Boston)
Choosing siding isn’t just about looks—it’s about weather protection, upkeep, budget, and long-term value. In the Boston area, siding has to handle wind-driven rain, snow/ice, and big seasonal swings, so picking the right material matters.
At Peak Quality Roofing, we install vinyl, fiber cement, and clapboard, plus cedar shingle/cedar shake by request—and we start with a free inspection to help you choose what fits your home and goals.
Quick comparison (homeowner-friendly)
Vinyl siding
Best if you want:
A cost-effective upgrade with strong curb appeal
Low maintenance (no repainting)
A wide variety of styles/colors
Fiber cement siding
Best if you want:
A more “solid” look and feel
Strong durability in harsh weather
High curb appeal and excellent resale perception
Clapboard siding (wood)
Best if you want:
A classic New England look that matches older homes
A premium, traditional aesthetic
You’re comfortable with ongoing maintenance (paint/stain upkeep)
How siding choices can affect resale value (ROI)
National remodeling data continues to show exterior upgrades (including siding) can deliver strong resale value retention. Zonda
In the 2025 Cost vs. Value Report, siding replacement projects are among the top ROI performers nationally:
Fiber cement siding replacement: ~114%
Vinyl siding replacement: ~97% Zonda
Boston ROI can differ by neighborhood and market timing, but the takeaway is simple: siding is often a “smart money” exterior upgrade.
What actually drives cost in Boston (more than the material)
Most homeowners are surprised that pricing isn’t just “vinyl vs fiber cement.” Key drivers include:
Home size + number of stories
Tear-off vs overlay
Trim detail and corner complexity
Rot repair / substrate issues
Window/door flashing updates
Access (tight city lots, landscaping, staging)
For local context, Angi maintains Boston-specific cost guides for vinyl and fiber cement siding installs. Angi
Maintenance reality check (what you’ll live with)
Vinyl (lowest maintenance)
Occasional wash
Great “set it and forget it” option
Fiber cement (moderate maintenance)
Usually needs repainting eventually (timing varies by exposure and paint system)
Excellent durability when installed correctly
Clapboard (highest maintenance)
Requires periodic paint/stain upkeep
If paint fails, moisture issues can follow—so maintenance matters
“Which siding is best for my home?”
Here’s the fastest way to decide:
Budget + low maintenance: start with vinyl
Upgraded look + durability: consider fiber cement
Historic/traditional aesthetic: consider clapboard (or cedar by request)
Not sure? Get a free inspection—sometimes the “right answer” is repair/partial replacement, not a full re-side.
Peak Quality Roofing’s siding team works with vinyl, fiber cement, and clapboard, with cedar shingles/shakes available by request.
FAQs
What siding is best for Boston weather?
Durability and moisture management matter most. Many homeowners choose vinyl for low maintenance or fiber cement for a more premium look.
Does new siding increase home value?
National ROI data suggests siding replacement can recoup a large portion of cost (and sometimes more), depending on the project type and market. Zonda
How do I know if I need replacement or repair?
A free inspection is the best start—especially to catch hidden rot or flashing issues.
