An Intermittent Dormer Leak Revealed a Bigger Roofing Problem

This homeowner contacted us after noticing recurring leaks around both front dormers of her Melrose home. Having purchased the property in 2020, she suspected the roof was approximately 26 years old and nearing replacement.

Our inspection revealed aging shingles, previous repairs, deteriorating flashing, and chimney masonry concerns. Rather than continuing with temporary fixes, the homeowner moved forward with a full roof replacement and chimney repointing.

Project Snapshot - Shauna Roofing Project

Project Snapshot

Overview
Location
Melrose, MA
Service
Full Roof Replacement + Chimney Repointing
Property Type
Residential Home
Primary Concern
Intermittent leaks around both front dormers
Key Findings
~26-year-old roof, widespread wear, prior repairs, vulnerable dormer/flashing details, deteriorated chimney mortar
Solution
Replace the aging roof system with CertainTeed Landmark Pro shingles, renew critical flashing, and repoint the chimney

The Inspection: The Dormer Leak Was Only Part of the Story

The first concern was the intermittent leaking around the two front dormers.

During the inspection, we found an open joint near the lower end of a dormer sidewall flashing - exactly the kind of roof-to-wall transition that can become vulnerable as materials age.

The rest of the roof provided important context. The approximately 26-year-old shingle system showed weathering, granule loss, staining, and multiple previous repairs.

Aging conditions were also documented at the chimney flashing and masonry, skylight flashing, and plumbing vent flashing.

Together, those findings showed a roofing system with several aging waterproofing details rather than one isolated trouble spot.

Next Photo
Slide titled "The Solution: Rebuild the Roof as One System" with an aerial photo of contractors replacing a home's roof down to the deck and installing CertainTeed underlayment.

THE SOLUTION: REBUILD THE ROOF AS ONE SYSTEM

Because the roof was already near the end of its expected service life and had been repaired in multiple locations, another spot repair would have left the remaining aging components in place.

The replacement plan allowed the vulnerable areas to be addressed together. The existing roofing was removed down to the deck so the underlying surface could be evaluated.

The new assembly included ice and water protection at critical areas, synthetic underlayment, new drip edge, renewed roof-to-wall and chimney flashing, ridge ventilation, and CertainTeed Landmark Pro architectural shingles.

The Chimney Was Addressed at the Same Time

The inspection also documented deteriorated mortar joints and previous repair materials around the chimney.

Instead of carrying those conditions into the new roof, the project included chimney repointing and replacement of the existing chimney flashing.

Addressing the masonry and roof-to-chimney transition together created a more complete correction at one of the roof's most important waterproofing areas.

What This Project Solves

Roofing work
01 roofing

Rebuilds the Dormer Leak Area

The vulnerable dormer transition that first prompted the call is rebuilt as part of the new roofing system instead of receiving another isolated patch.

Roof flashing work
02 construction

Ends the Cycle of Aging Patch Repairs

Widespread weathering and multiple previous repairs are replaced with one integrated roofing system, reducing reliance on repeated spot work as different areas age.

Low slope roofing
03 layers

Renews the Roof’s Critical Water-Entry Points

Chimney, roof-to-wall, skylight, plumbing vent, and other flashing details are addressed as part of the reroof so the new shingles are supported by renewed transition details.

Roof edge and fascia
04 shield

Corrects Deteriorated Chimney Masonry Alongside the Roof

Repointing addresses deteriorated mortar while the new flashing rebuilds the connection between the chimney and roofing system, avoiding the need to treat them as separate problems later.

Next Photo

A Fresh Start for an Aging Melrose Roof

What began as an intermittent leak around the front dormers led to a clearer picture of an aging roof with several vulnerable details. By replacing the roof as a complete system and addressing the chimney masonry at the same time, the project moved beyond another round of patching.

The home now has a new CertainTeed Landmark Pro architectural shingle roofing system with renewed waterproofing and flashing details, along with repointed chimney masonry - a more complete foundation for protecting the home moving forward.

Not Sure Which Part of Your Roof Actually Needs Attention?

Lynn, MA, USA

Need Help Understanding What's Happening With Your Roof?

A leak does not automatically mean a roof needs to be replaced.

A complete inspection can help show whether the problem is isolated or part of a broader pattern of aging and deterioration.

Peak Quality Roofing provides homeowners in Melrose and surrounding communities with a Free Roof Inspection so they can understand the condition of the roof and the options available.

Melrose, MA, USA

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I know whether a roof leak needs a repair or full replacement?

It depends on the source of the leak and the overall condition of the roof. A localized issue on an otherwise serviceable roof may be repairable, while widespread aging, repeated repairs, and deteriorating flashing can make replacement a more appropriate option to consider.

Can dormer flashing cause roof leaks?

Yes. Dormers create roof-to-wall transitions where flashing is critical. Open joints, aging flashing, or deteriorated materials at these transitions can create vulnerable areas for water intrusion.

Should chimney flashing and masonry be addressed during a reroof?

When the chimney flashing or surrounding masonry is deteriorated, reroofing is an opportunity to address those conditions while the roofing system is being rebuilt. On this project, the scope included both chimney repointing and new chimney flashing.

What shingles were specified for this Melrose roof replacement?

The project scope specified CertainTeed Landmark Pro architectural asphalt shingles.

Does Peak Quality Roofing offer roof inspections in Melrose, MA?

Yes. Peak Quality Roofing provides Free Roof Inspections for homeowners in Melrose and surrounding communities.

We provide honest roof inspections and clear reports so you can make confident decisions about your home.

OUR SERVICES

Certifications & Trust
Fully licensed, bonded, and certified for top-tier quality standards.
BBB Accredited A+ Rating
GAF Certified Factory Master
CertainTeed ShingleMaster

SERVICE LOCATIONS

OFFICE LOCATION

58 Mount Vernon Ave, Melrose, MA 02176

58 Mt Vernon Ave, Melrose, MA 02176, USA

Copyright 2025. All rights reserved.