This project involved a rental property in Malden, MA. The customer initially reached out looking for a full reroof of the main structure.
During the inspection, we found that several smaller roof sections, including porch and dormer areas, had been reroofed more recently and were still in relatively good condition. However, the main roof was a different story. It had older three-tab asphalt shingles, several missing or damaged areas, signs of previous repairs, and visible weathering that showed the roof was approaching the end of its reliable service life.
The inspection also revealed a major chimney issue. The chimney had deteriorated mortar joints, visible structural wear, no chimney cap, and a base that appeared to have been sealed with roof cement instead of a proper flashing system. Based on these findings, we recommended a full replacement of the main roof along with a chimney rebuild from the roofline up.
The customer specifically asked us to evaluate the chimney because other contractors had suggested that repointing might be enough.
After a closer inspection, it became clear that repointing would not properly address the full condition of the chimney. The masonry showed deteriorated mortar joints, visible structural wear, and the chimney base had been sealed with roof cement rather than a proper flashing system.
This roof inspection in Malden, MA helped uncover issues that were not limited to the shingles. The chimney, flashing, pipe boots, and fascia details all affected the final recommendation.
Key findings included:
Main roof near the end of its service life
Older three-tab asphalt shingles
Missing and damaged shingles
Prior repair attempts, including overlapping or layered shingles
Chimney base sealed with roof cement instead of proper flashing
Deteriorated chimney mortar joints
Visible chimney structural wear
No chimney cap observed
Pipe and vent flashing concerns
Missing fascia aluminum section
The main roof showed clear signs of age and weather exposure. The existing three-tab asphalt shingles were heavily worn, and several sections had missing or damaged shingles that left vulnerable areas exposed.
We also found areas where previous repairs had been layered over the existing roof surface. These patch repairs may have helped temporarily, but they did not solve the larger issue: the main roof was no longer performing reliably as a full system.
Because the wear was widespread across the main roof, a full replacement was the better long-term solution.

At first, the chimney may have seemed like it only needed repointing. But the inspection showed that the issue was more serious.
The chimney had deteriorated mortar joints, visible structural wear, and no chimney cap. The base of the chimney also appeared to have been sealed with roof cement instead of a properly integrated chimney flashing system.
Because the masonry showed visible wear and the chimney flashing had been patched with roof cement, this became more than a basic chimney repair in Malden. A chimney rebuild was the better long-term solution because it allowed the damaged masonry and flashing area to be corrected together.
The inspection also identified several roofline details that needed attention beyond the main shingles and chimney.
Pipe and vent flashing concerns were observed, which can become future leak points if not corrected during the roofing work. A section of fascia aluminum was also missing and needed replacement.
By addressing these details as part of the same project, the work could be completed as a more complete roof system instead of only replacing the visible shingles.

This project used a full GAF asphalt roofing system with supporting materials for chimney flashing, ventilation, fascia repair, and roofline protection.
Important materials included:
GAF Timberline HDZ shingles in Hickory
GAF Pro-Start Starter Strip Shingles
GAF Seal-A-Ridge Hip & Ridge Shingles
Synthetic underlayment
Ice and water shield
Aluminum drip edge
Ridge vent system
Step flashing
Lead flashing roll
Pipe boot flashing materials
Roofing nails, cap nails, staples, and sealants
Aluminum trim coil for fascia repair
Lumber and plywood for repair areas where needed
These materials supported the main roof replacement, chimney rebuild, flashing replacement, ventilation upgrade, and fascia repair work identified during the inspection.
The chimney rebuild was a key part of the project because the chimney connects directly into the surrounding roofing system.
When a chimney has deteriorated mortar, structural wear, poor flashing, or no cap, it can create risk around the roofline, attic, and interior spaces. Rebuilding the chimney from the roofline up allowed us to correct the masonry issue and install a properly integrated flashing system with the new roof.
Rebuilding the chimney also allowed us to complete the chimney flashing repair properly, so the new roof system and masonry work could function together.

Not every section of the property needed to be replaced. During the inspection, we identified smaller roof sections that had been reroofed more recently and were still in relatively good condition.
That helped create a more practical recommendation for the customer. Instead of treating every roof section the same way, we focused on the areas that truly needed work: the main roof, chimney, flashing, ventilation, fascia, and vulnerable roof penetrations.
This gave the customer a clearer scope of work and helped avoid unnecessary replacement of roof sections that were still performing.
After reviewing the roof, chimney, flashing, and fascia conditions, we completed a targeted scope of work designed to restore the main roofing system and correct the chimney area properly.
Key outcomes included:
Full reroof of the main house
Removal of aging three-tab asphalt shingles
Installation of new GAF Timberline HDZ shingles in Hickory
Installation of synthetic underlayment
Installation of ice and water protection
New drip edge installation
New ridge vent installation
Pipe and vent flashing corrections
Complete chimney rebuild from the roofline up
New chimney flashing system
New chimney cap installation
Replacement of missing fascia aluminum
Supporting flashing, sealants, fasteners, trim, lumber, and plywood where needed
This approach allowed us to focus the work where it mattered most: the aging main roof, the structurally compromised chimney, and the roofline details that support long-term protection.
Many Malden homes and rental properties have roofing systems that were repaired or updated in stages over time. Some sections may still be in good condition, while other areas may be near the end of their service life.
That is why a detailed inspection is important. It helps identify what actually needs replacement, what can stay, and whether related areas like chimneys, flashing, ventilation, fascia, pipe boots, and trim need attention.
For homeowners looking for a roof replacement contractor in Malden, MA, this project shows why a detailed inspection can change the scope from a simple reroof to a more complete roof, chimney, and flashing solution.
Peak Quality Roofing helps Malden property owners make clear, practical roofing decisions based on the actual condition of the home.
The inspection showed that the main roof was aging and no longer performing reliably, with missing shingles, weathered three-tab shingles, and signs of previous patch repairs. The chimney also had deteriorated mortar joints, visible structural wear, and poor flashing conditions, so both systems needed to be addressed together.
Repointing only repairs mortar joints. In this case, the chimney showed deeper issues, including visible structural wear, deteriorated masonry, no chimney cap, and a base that had been sealed with roof cement instead of a proper flashing system. Because of that, rebuilding the chimney from the roofline up was the better long-term recommendation.
Not every roof section was in the same condition. Some smaller roof sections, including porch and dormer areas, had been reroofed more recently and were still performing well. The inspection helped separate the areas that needed replacement from the areas that could remain.
The main roof was replaced using a GAF asphalt roofing system, including GAF Timberline HDZ shingles in Hickory, starter shingles, ridge cap shingles, synthetic underlayment, ice and water shield, drip edge, ridge vent, flashing materials, and supporting fasteners and sealants.
Chimney flashing helps direct water away from the area where the chimney meets the roof. If flashing is missing, poorly installed, or covered with roof cement, water can enter around the chimney and lead to roof leaks, attic moisture, or interior damage.
This project shows why a detailed inspection matters. What may look like a basic roof replacement can also involve chimney structure, flashing, ventilation, pipe boots, and fascia details. Reviewing the full system helps homeowners avoid temporary fixes and make a more informed long-term decision.
CUSTOMER CARE
OFFICE LOCATION
58 Mount Vernon Ave, Melrose, MA 02176
FOLLOW US ON
Copyright 2025. All rights reserved.
Website by Pure Value Advisors